It's tough to avoid violence in film these days. I haven't been all that thrilled about the clear and present increasing role that blood and gore plays in on the big screen the last decade. For a time, the violence factor forced me to pass on films I might otherwise have enjoyed. But I couldn't pass on Kingdom of Heaven, Gladiator, and The Patriot... couldn't skip Seraphim Falls and Rambo... and I needed to experience Pearl Harbor, We Were Soldiers, Saving Private Ryan, and The Passion of the Christ.
I have reconsidered my position on the role of violence in film. I still don't like it, but there is a part of me that believes that violence SHOULD play a role in the way a film tells its story when it is neccessary. Violence for the "gross out" factor is violence I will never support; blood and gore as an ingredient to the story is far difference from blood and gore AS the story i.e. the Saw franchise, Kill Bill.
Many of my fellow Christians would argue that advocating violence in film is against the principles of our faith. Yet I would respond that any decent perusal of the Biblical text will reveal as much brutal violence as any stomach can tolerate. The Biblical text doesn't leave much to the imagination when describing one of the Hebrew judges burying his knife (quite literally) into the obese stomach of an enemy leader, or what happened to Judas's body when its weight snapped the tree branch. And in fact the brutality that Jesus suffered at the hands of the Romans is meant to sober us as to just what it cost for our eternal redemption.
But what of the children? True that we should protect their innocence--and especially our daughters. But there comes a time when they all need to realise that this world isn't a cuddly place. Sooner or later they must learn that Heaven is as forever wonderful as this world is terrible--indeed hell with be far more terrible and brutal than this world ever will be. And boys must become men, for it is we that must protect our charges from the violent brutality of evil.
So where do we draw the line? I may admit that violence is necessary, but that doesn't mean that I believe God wants us to bathe in blood. As a writer, I always know when adding too much of a certain plot device is too much. As a student of film I can always tell when the filmmaker goes to far. The camera should never linger on violent acts, never draw them out; and violent act after violent act--no matter how swift--will start to numb the brain, and that isn't effective either.
The filmmaker must realise (and the vast majority do) when their blood and gore ceases to be the result of an equation and becomes mere spectacle. And although we cannot protect our children forever, violent films should not be created specifically for nor marketed directly to them--allow them their time of innocence; children should never be raised to believe that violence is cool or the first choice in a situation. They should be exposed to it as fact and the end-result of a sinful human nature, but never as glorified art.
When your Maximus voice cries, "Are you not entertained?" during a violent film, consider your response.
Recent Comments